Understanding the Sandwich Franchise Landscape
The U.S. sandwich shop franchise sector is projected to grow steadily in 2025, with total sales surpassing $23 billion annually. Franchises make up a major share of this sector, with approximately 38,000 sandwich-focused franchise units nationwide. This growth aligns with the overall expansion of franchising in the U.S., which is forecast to rise 4.4% in 2025, outpacing general economic growth (IFA 2025 Economic Outlook Report [Franchise.org]).
Consumer behavior plays a central role in this growth. Around half of U.S. adults eat a sandwich daily (About half of U.S. adults eat a sandwich daily [USDA/ARS NHANES data brief]). Sandwiches are viewed as convenient, customizable, and relatively healthy, fitting modern dietary habits. This behavior has enabled the sandwich franchise model to remain resilient in a shifting food economy.
The market is not without disruption, however. While fast-growing chains like Jersey Mike’s expand rapidly, legacy brands such as Subway continue to shrink their U.S. footprint (Subway’s U.S. Count Keeps Declining). Differentiation, craveable menu items, and digital readiness are now central to staying competitive.
What Consumers Want—and What Franchises Must Deliver
The demand for craveable menu items, customization, and value shapes modern sandwich franchise performance. Satisfying a craving tops the list of needs a customer is trying to satisfy when choosing a limited service restaurant, surpassing the need for ‘better for you’ or convenience (Technomic 2024). Customization also weighs heavily in customer decision making: Build-your-own menu items appeal to a range of dietary needs, from gluten-free to high-protein and plant-based. 58% of customers will recommend a QSR based on a positive customized ordering experience. (Tillster’s 2024 Phygital Index Report)
At the same time, digital ordering has become vital. Mobile orders, delivery apps, and in-store kiosks now make up a significant portion of sales for most QSR brands. Approximately one-third of restaurant sales are now digital, creating new demands for app integration, CRM systems, and cloud-based POS platforms (Digital Ordering and Unified Platforms – Deloitte Restaurant of the Future Report). Franchises must support robust mobile platforms and ensure seamless ordering experiences.
Three Operational Drivers of Top Performers
1. Unified Technology and Ordering Systems
Beyond simply being convenient, digital platforms are also robust profit engines. Unified POS systems cohesively manage in-restaurant, brand eCommerce, and 3rd party orders. Paired with customer-facing apps, the result is often better labor productivity and faster service. Integrated Rewards Programs allow for personalized promotions and provide cost-efficient solutions for influencing incremental customer visits.
2. Operational and Labor Efficiency
Efficiency across day-to-day operations is a key profitability driver. Top-performing franchises streamline kitchen workflows, optimize staffing models, and deploy scheduling tools that match labor to demand. Reliable back-of-house systems reduce food waste and enhance order accuracy. While emerging automation tools are gaining attention, it is consistent operational execution and process optimization that continue to deliver the most measurable results today.
Also read:
3. Cost Management Discipline
Controlling both variable and fixed costs is critical to sustainable profitability. Technology investments should be measured against the incremental efficiencies or revenue they generate, avoiding cost creep from unnecessary tools. Proven operational processes, like precise food prep and inventory management, minimize waste and protect margins. While automation holds promise for future cost reductions, today’s leaders focus on mastering the fundamentals of efficient, data-driven cost control.
Franchise System Strengths and Owner Support
The backbone of any sandwich franchise investment lies in its systems. Key benefits include national brand recognition, group purchasing power, efficient processes, and effective operational support. For example, franchisees entering an established system receive training in marketing, food prep, hiring, and financial management. This standardized support reduces the guesswork and errors of independent business ownership (Understanding Franchise Operations Support: What Franchisors Owe You).
Most franchise support systems offer location selection assistance and territory exclusivity, ensuring minimal overlap with other units. Marketing funds (usually 2–3% of gross sales) go toward collective advertising, while operating manuals and field support ensure operational consistency. High-performing systems, such as Penn Station East Coast Subs, also report high franchisee satisfaction (Penn Station franchisee satisfaction [Franchise Business Review]).
Related read:
Franchise marketing support, promoting your brand
What It Costs—and What You Might Earn
Initial investments for a sandwich franchise typically range from $400,000 to $800,000. For instance, Jimmy John’s estimates startup costs between $366,000 and $728,000 (Jimmy John’s FDD Summary [SharpSheets 2025]), while Penn Station East Coast Subs reports $474,000 to $765,000 (Penn Station East Coast Subs Franchise Disclosure [FranchisePayback]).
Revenue benchmarks vary, but average unit volumes (AUV) in the sector tend to land between $770,000 and $935,000 annually. Net profit margins for QSRs typically range from 6–9% (Fast‑food and QSR profit margins [DoorDash]). That means a store doing $850,000 in sales might net $46,750–$76,500 before taxes and debt service.
Royalty and marketing fees reduce gross revenue. Jimmy John’s and Penn Station both charge royalties around 6%, plus 2–3% in ad fees. These costs must be factored into ROI projections. According to analysts, investors should target a payback period of under 5 years for strong-performing stores (What’s a Good Franchise ROI? [Vetted Biz]).
Penn Station Case Study: A Proven Model with Strong Support
Penn Station East Coast Subs provides a useful case study. With over 320 U.S. locations and a focus on grilled subs, fresh-cut fries, and fresh-squeezed lemonade, the brand emphasizes a highly craveable menu and simplicity of operation. Startup costs fall between $508,000 to $859,000.
The company also requires a minimum net worth of $500,000 and $300,000 in liquid capital.
Its AUV is approximately $771,000, Royalties average 6% (depending on sales), and marketing contributions are 3%. Franchisees benefit from territory protection, multi-week training programs, and ongoing field support. Importantly, 98% of owners surveyed reported enjoying the business and would recommend it (Successful Restaurant Franchises Testimonials).
With its time-tested strategy, Penn Station’s clear operational playbook, support infrastructure, and brand consistency make it a practical option for investors seeking long-term value.
Final Evaluation Criteria for 2025
To assess a sandwich shop franchise opportunity:
- Validate market demand in your area, including sandwich consumption habits and competitive saturation.
- Analyze the brand’s performance (e.g., AUV, store growth, franchisee satisfaction, etc.)
- Project realistic financial outcomes using conservative margin estimates and fee structures.
- Review the Franchise Disclosure Document (FDD) for details on royalties, territory, and training.
- Understand the franchisor’s support model for onboarding, marketing, and operations.
Investors who follow this structured process while focusing on brand alignment, financial feasibility, and operational support will be best positioned to succeed in the sandwich franchise space in 2025.
